1.Introduction
1.1
Worcestershire County Council has a commitment to the provision of high quality
services within the context of legislative requirements.
In respect of
young people who are ‘looked after’ by the local authority, the need for a policy relating to personal
relationships and sexual health is highlighted in the 1989 Children Act:
"The
experience of being cared for should also include the sexual education of the young person… This
is absolutely vital since sexuality will be one of the most potent forces affecting any young person
in the transition from childhood to adulthood."
Guidance & Regulations
also emphasise that the particular needs of different groups of young people must be recognised and
approached sympathetically, for instance young people with physical or learning disabilities, young
people who have been abused and young gay men and lesbians.
Article 24
of the United Nations’ Convention on the Rights of the Child emphasises the rights of all children to
health care services (1989). This has been reinforced by Human Rights Act, 2000.
The
1994 Audit Commission Report ‘Seen But Not Heard’ identifies the health of children and young people
in public care as poorer than that of the general population.
Sir William
Utting in ‘People Like Us’ (1997) makes clear the importance of age appropriate sex education and goes
on to emphasise that sex education protocols should be drawn up by care agencies.
The
Government strategy on reducing teenage pregnancy, has resulted in Worcestershire County Council and
Worcestershire Health Authority, producing "Tackling Teenage Pregnancy and Paternity in Worcestershire
- A 10 year Strategy".
Included in this document is a 3-year
rolling action plan. Recognising that children and young people in public care are a vulnerable
group who need particular attention, the plan identifies specific tasks, with timescales, that will
address their needs.
The Teenage Pregnancy Unit has produced guidelines:
‘Guidance for Field Social Workers, Residential Social Workers and Foster Carers on Providing Information
and Referring Young People to Contraceptive and Sexual Health Services’.
Quality
Protects sub-objective 4.2 aims to:
"Ensure that children looked
after enjoy a standard of health and development as good as all children of the same age living in the
same area."
1.2 Many young
people looked after will have had inadequate or damaging life experiences. Such experiences are
likely to distort their understanding of personal relationships and sexual behaviour. Developing
appropriate personal relationships, and an understanding of sexual behaviour and sexuality, are fundamental
to their maturation and future well being.
This document is intended
to support carers when dealing with this complex and sensitive area.
1.3
The policy is the result of collaboration between Children's
Services Directorate and Worcestershire NHS. In addition, information was gathered from young
people
currently looked after and staff in the County’s Residential Children’s Homes.
1.4
Whilst acknowledging that this policy is intended to support the carers of all
children Looked After, work is currently being undertaken to further develop practice guidelines for
those carers who assume responsibility for children with disabilities.
1.5
For ease of reference:
‘Carers’ refers to those
with day to day responsibility for the young people, primarily Residential Social Workers (RSW&’s)
and foster carers.
‘Young People’ include both children and young people
who are ‘looked after’ by the local authority.
‘Education’ refers to
support, guidance and advice.
2. Aim of the Policy
To
enable carers to work effectively with young people on all personal relationship issues.3.
3. Objectives of the Policy
4. Anti-Discriminatory Practice
A
young person’s welfare is paramount when making decisions about their upbringing. When promoting
issues of sexual health, carers must always take into account issues of race, culture, gender, religion,
disability, sexuality and HIV status, as they relate to the young person.
It
is recognised that carers hold their own cultural, religious and moral beliefs and whilst they will
not be expected to alter those beliefs, they should not, however, impose those beliefs on young people,
where they differ from the guidance within this policy.
It is acknowledged
that stereotypes exist. When considering personal relationships and sexual health issues therefore,
carers will be expected to actively challenge such stereotypes.
Disabled
young people and young people with learning difficulties have an equal right to accurate information
on personal relationships and sexual health that is appropriate to their age and understanding, and
their disability should not preclude them from having fulfilling personal and sexual relationships.
To
ensure that information is accessible to young people and their carers it may be necessary to use translation,
interpretation, signing and Braille services.
Black young people, young
women and lesbian, gay and bisexual young people are particularly vulnerable to sexualised verbal abuse
and carers need to be sensitive to young people facing such discrimination.
Young
people themselves may also use sexualised language towards their peers which carers will need to challenge.
Sexual
health/advice is not just about providing information about sex but also putting this into a context
in terms of relationships, emotions, choice and exploitation. This is particularly important when
considering the needs of girls/young women and those young people who have been sexually abused.
In
terms of anti-discriminatory practice carers have a responsibility to examine their own beliefs and
how that affects the work they carry out.
5. Policy Framework
5.1
Morals and Values
We, as a service, do not
believe ignorance protects. As such our framework of values for sex and relationships education,
to which we all subscribe, attempts to foster:
This
policy is also framed within the context of legislative requirements, and departmental childcare policies
and procedures. ‘Best Practice’ will be achieved through:
6. Legal Framework
Local
Authorities’ duties and responsibilities with regard to personal relationships of young people looked
after are contained in legislation and case law, the most important statute being the Children Act 1989
6.1 Children Act 1989
In relation to sexuality and young people looked after, the Government has issued guidance on the implementation of the Children Act:
It is a criminal offence
for a boy or man to have intercourse of any kind or sexual contact with a girl who is under 16. It
is not an offence for the girl, who is deemed incapable in law of consenting to a sexual act if she
is under 16. Boys as young as 10 can commit offences involving sexual intercourse: s.1 Sexual
Offences Act 1993 abolished the legal presumption that a boy under 14 was incapable of achieving sexual
intercourse.
In practice prosecution is unlikely for a boy under 17,
unless he is considerably older than the girl, or the girl does not consent. There is a greater
likelihood of men over 17 being prosecuted and the penalties they incur are likely to be more severe.
Sexual offences against girls under 13 are considered more serious in law and incur a heavier
penalty.
6.2 Lesbian and Gay Sexual Acts
There
is no legislation of any kind, which is specifically concerned with sex between women. However,
a woman aged over 16 can be charged with indecent assault for any kind of sexual contact with a girl
under 16. From 2001, the age of consent was equalised at 16, for both heterosexual and homosexual
activity.
6.3 Age of Consent to Medical Treatment
The
Children Act 1989 Guidance and Regulations, Volume 3 - Family Placements states "Children who are
judged able to give consent cannot be medically examined or treated without their consent. The
responsible Authority should draw the child’s attention to his/her right to give or refuse consent to
examination or treatment. The doctor(s) decides whether a young person is capable of giving/witholding
consent and understanding the consequences of their action.
6.4 Contraception and Girls under 16
The
Gillick Case involved a challenge by Victoria Gillick to guidance issued by the DHSS in 1980 on family
planning services for young people. She objected to the guidance because although it emphasised
that doctors should attempt to persuade the young person to involve their parents, it accepted that
there were ‘exceptional’ circumstances when confidential advice and treatment could be provided to people
under the age of consent. In 1986 the House of Lords, while emphasising that girls under 16 seeking
contraceptive advice should be encouraged to inform their parents, upheld the right of doctors to prescribe
contraceptives without parental knowledge or consent. Guidance to doctors and health professionals
is now to be found in the Fraser Guidelines (based on the judgements of Lord Fraser in the Gillick case).
6.5 Implications of the Fraser Guidelines
It
is an offence for a person to cause or encourage the commission of unlawful sexual intercourse with
a girl under the age of 16 for whom they are responsible. However "The only situation in
which it would be unlawful would be where it could be proved that advice was given to a young person
(or an adult) with the intention of facilitating sexual intercourse with a girl under 16. In such
a case the adviser concerned could be charged with being an accessory to the crime of unlawful sexual
intercourse." In practice no such charge has ever occurred. The Fraser Guidelines
have been construed more widely to apply to any medical or dental treatment, or care. Provision
of any medical treatment to a child may be a trespass to the person and constitute an assault in law
if consent to such treatment is not obtained.
In the judgement, the
House of Lords concluded that the duration of parental rights could not be determined with reference
to a child attaining a certain age but upon a judgement of what was best for the welfare of a particular
child. It was concluded that a doctor would be justified in proceeding without the parents’ consent
provided they were satisfied of the following:
1.
that a young person would understand the advice;
2. that the doctor
could not persuade the young person to inform the parents or allow the doctor to inform the parents
that they were seeking medical advice;
3. that the young person was
very likely to be at risk without medical advice or intervention;
4.
that unless the young person received advice or treatment their physical or mental health or both were
likely to suffer;
5. that their best interests
required the doctor to give advice, treatment or both without parental consent.
The Fraser Guidelines primarily give guidance to Health professionals. This states that professionals should take care not to undermine parental responsibility. Advice may be given without parental consent if the professional is satisfied that:
1. the young person can understand the advice and
has sufficient maturity to understand what is involved in terms of the moral, social, and emotional
implications;
2. the professional can neither
persuade the young person to inform the parents, nor allow him/her to inform them, that advice was being
sought;
3. the young person would be very likely
to begin to be at risk without medical advice or treatment;
4. without
advice the young person’s physical or mental health, or both would be likely to suffer;
5.
the young person’s best interests require the professional to give advice without parental consent.
6.6 1987 Local Government Bill (Clause
28)
This legislation, despite popular belief, does not forbid
either the provision of information or the counselling of young people who are or who think they may
be lesbian or gay. Discussion of sexuality and sexual feelings is a vital part of education around
relationships.
The legislation, which has never been used in court, is
due to be repealed.
7. Practice Guidelines
7.1
RSW’s, foster carers, SWs and Family Support workers are highly skilled at developing
relationships with young people. Communication is vital and the best discussions around personal
relationships and sexual health often occur informally and spontaneously, e.g. washing up, over a meal,
watching TV. All of these situations offer good opportunities to talk about such diverse subjects
as safer sexual practices, love, friendship, child abuse, homophobia, teenage pregnancy, termination
of pregnancy etc. It is at these times that we can discuss important values and information with
young people in an open and non-threatening way.
7.2
Young people want the opportunity to talk to adults they know and can trust
about relationships and sexual health. This will not promote sexual activity. Teenagers
who are able to openly discuss sex and relationships are more likely to make informed choices with regard
to what they do and do not want from relationships.
7.3
Young people ‘looked after’ must be encouraged to promote their own protection
and develop responsibility in the sexual expression of their relationships. Access to advice services
should be proactively sought, rather than as a response to a crisis. Failure to do this would
only serve to endorse the message that sexual health matters are a ‘problem’.
7.4
It is essential that we take account of a young person’s age and understanding
and work in partnership with those with parental responsibility. This can include offering help
and advice to parents which can assist them in supporting their child.
7.5
Our own feelings of embarrassment or our beliefs can make it hard to talk to
young people. RSW’s and foster carers who are unable to discuss specific sex and relationship
issues with young people, have a responsibility to advise them where to go for help and support. In
some placement settings, e.g. residential homes, there is an expectation that staff members will make
known to colleagues any personally held beliefs, which will affect their ability to engage with young
people on certain aspects of relationships. In all circumstances, the rights of the child must be paramount.
8. Confidentiality
Carers do not
have a duty to inform parents of evidence or suspicion of sexual activity; however, it is a principle
of the Children Act that they should work in partnership whenever possible and appropriate. Clearly,
there are some situations where this may not be an appropriate role for a carer, e.g. if a young person
becomes pregnant or seeks a termination. Whenever there is concern for the well-being of a young
person, carers should liaise with the young person’s social worker to agree the appropriate course of
action.
Information relating to sex, sexuality and personal relationships
can often be very sensitive and carers should not divulge such information without the prior knowledge
and preferably consent of the young person to whom the information relates. Information that is
recorded should be stored securely so that unauthorised people cannot have easy access to it. Good
practice should involve the routine sharing of information that is recorded with the young person.
As
discussions around sexual issues may result in disclosure of abuse, it is essential that young people
are aware, from the start, that any such disclosures involving themselves or any other young person
will be passed on. RSW’s and foster carers need to be clear about what constitutes abuse and Children's
Services Child Protection Procedures MUST be followed.
9. Application of Policy
9.1
For children under 10 years of age
The work to
be done with the young person needs to be identified in the child’s Placement Plan part 2, (health)
and section 12 of the Care Plan, which is concerned with the long-term needs of the child. This
will involve giving age appropriate information to help them:
9.2 For children over 10 years of age
The
need for support and advice on personal relationship issues will be identified in the Assessment and
Action Records (H16 to H20), the Placement Plan part 2, section 2, (health) and section 4 (identity);
as well as section 12 of the Care Plan, which is concerned with the long-term needs of young people.
The expectation would be that areas identified in 8.1 are expanded upon, appropriate to age and
understanding, including:
9.3 Working with Parents
Working
in partnership with parents is identified as a key principle of the Children Act. Consistency
and understanding between carers and those who hold parental responsibility will always benefit young
people, but particularly in the area of sexual health.
Agreement to discuss
relationships and sexual health matters with young people should be sought from those with parental
responsibility, prior to the initial planning meeting - consultation should then follow as a matter
of course. However, if the young person does not wish their parents to be consulted, and is of
sufficient age and understanding, their wishes should be respected.
Where
the young person’s welfare would be prejudiced by informing his/her carers, work can continue without
parents/carers having to be informed. It is important, in this event, that the position should
be reviewed regularly. This responsibility lies with the Child Care Team Manager, through an allocated
social worker.
A clear written record of decisions and actions must be
kept in the young person’s case file.
Persons with parental responsibility
should be given information relating to any sexual health education programmes available to their child.
This will ensure that they have the opportunity to express their concerns or wishes. Parents
often find talking to their children about sex and relationships difficult, and talking to another adult
can be beneficial, i.e. Children & Families Social Worker, Residential Social Worker, Family Support
Worker, Foster Carer, Teacher, Health Worker.
Some parents may have religious/cultural
beliefs that affect their views. These need to be acknowledged and respected. Ensuring information/communication
is available to parents in an accessible format will increase their confidence and trust in the information
given. (See 9.5).
It is essential to consult with the young person
before divulging any information about their sexual activity to their parents. If there appears
to be a child protection issue, departmental guidelines will always be followed.
9.4 Review Process
The
health and education of young people are important issues that need to be addressed throughout the review
process. In relation to issues of sexual health and education, the following need to be considered:
9.5 Religion, Culture & Sex Education
Young
people ‘looked after’ by the local authority come from a variety of cultural and religious backgrounds.
This may impact on how sex education may be delivered and at what age. However, this does
not mean some young people should be denied the benefits of receiving sex education. There are
several points which will support carers in this task:
9.6 Contraception
9.7 Sexual Relationships in Placement
Being
‘looked after’ can highlight many feelings and emotions and these can present particular challenges
during times of sexual development. Living away from home could result in young people developing
relationships that have a sexual element (Bremner, J & Hillin, A (1993)).
Whilst
carers need to recognise and respect young people’s feelings, it is considered unacceptable for sexual
activity, involving young people ‘looked after’, to take place within Children's Services community
homes.
Family
placements may want to consider a range of ‘house rules’ depending on a young person’s age, circumstances,
customs and beliefs. Whatever these are agreed to be, an open discussion amongst carers, social
workers, young people, and parents where appropriate, is vital if the young person is to understand
what is and what is not acceptable.
There are several points to keep
in mind when addressing this issue.
9.8 Safer Sex
Information
and advice on safer sex, HIV, Hepatitis and other sexually transmitted infections such as Chlamydia
is very important. Carers need accurate and up to date information on local services and how to
access them.
Young people have a right to be tested, once they are able
to make an informed choice. The opportunity to discuss this with carers and professional counsellors
should be made available. Carers should advise young people of clinics where anonymity and appropriate
pre- and post- testing counselling is available. Young people should be advised against testing
without their having access to appropriate counselling services. Not all the carers working with
a young person need to be informed of their HIV or Hepatitis status, e.g. the whole of the RSW team
in a residential unit. Information relating to a young person’s blood-borne viral status should
be shared on a ‘need to know’ basis, and the young person consulted. No young person will be discriminated
against as a result of such a disclosure. First aid and control of infection practice, should
always follow current guidelines and assume that blood spills can be infectious in some circumstances.
9.9 Sexuality
Sexual
health information and education should be supportive of and responsive to the needs of all young people
being ‘looked after’ including those exploring their sexual identity and/or those identifying themselves
as gay, lesbian or bisexual.
This is clearly stated in the Children Act:
"…the needs and concerns of gay young men and women must be recognised
and approached sympathetically…"
"…some young people may need
considerable counselling before they come to accept themselves… Gay young men and women may require
sympathetic carers to enable them to accept their sexuality and to develop their own self identity."
This
policy offers support to young people experiencing discrimination on the basis of their sexuality. In
practice this means that same sex relationships should be acknowledged and valued so that young lesbians,
gay men and bisexual young people value themselves and their relationships.
Some
points to consider when dealing with this issue are:
9.10 Pornography
Pornographic
material containing sexually explicit images is often degrading and offensive and the department does
not support its use or availability. Pornographic material can only be purchased by adults aged
18 years and over therefore if a young person is found to be in possession of pornographic material,
it should be removed from them with sensitivity. In addition the opportunity should be taken to
discuss with them how such material could lead to the development of a distorted view of sexuality and
degrade the dignity of the individual.
9.11 Masturbation
Masturbation
is part of normal sexual behaviour, particularly for young people who are exploring their emerging sexuality.
Young people should not be made to feel guilty or embarrassed about masturbation or to be prevented
from doing it. It is important however, that young people understand the social conventions associated
with sexual behaviour in general and masturbation in particular, in that it is a private activity.
9.12 Pregnancy
Young,
pregnant women face many difficulties. Young pregnant women who are ‘looked after’, face even
more. Isolation from their families often results in a lack of support. They may face criticism
and prejudice about their sexual behaviour. It is vital that guidance and support is made available
to them, to enable them to make informed choices about their future and that of their baby.
The
following will assist carers when dealing with this:
10. Children’s Rights
Young People
‘looked after’ have a right to be provided with the same information that is available to young people,
of the same age, in the local community. Carers should ensure that:
11. Information & Advice
Young
people who are ‘looked after’ are entitled to receive information and guidance appropriate to their
individual needs. This information should include access to information on sexual health services, and
the legal framework of sexual activity.
Information should cover a range
of issues, not just be based on sexual facts, but should incorporate an understanding of different kinds
of relationships, values, attitudes and moral issues.
12. Professional Boundaries & Safe Practice
Maintaining
appropriate boundaries between the carer and the young person is particularly important in relation
to matters concerning personal relationships. While carers need to provide young people with opportunities
to safely discuss and explore their emerging sexuality and sexual behaviour, this must at all times
be undertaken in a professional context.
For further guidance, please
refer to ‘Towards Safer Care in Worcestershire’ (February 2000).
Many
young people who are ‘looked after’ by the department have had previous experiences of abuse and involvement
in high-risk lifestyles. This may influence their response to work undertaken with them concerning
personal relationships and sexuality. Young people may misinterpret situations and conversations
and on occasions make allegations against carers. Caution must be observed by carers in sharing
their own personal life experiences which, however well-intended, may be open to misrepresentation and
misunderstanding by the young person. If in any doubt, carers should discuss with their supervisor
the most appropriate means of working with a young person in this area.
Under
no circumstances would it be acceptable for a carer to engage in a sexual relationship with a young
person in their care.
13. Support, Supervision & Training
The
implementation of this policy relies on carers receiving appropriate support, supervision and training.
To this end, the following points will need to be addressed:
14. Dissemination of this Policy
A
full copy of this policy and practice guidance will be made available to those Children's services staff
employed within Children’s Services, and given to all approved foster carers.
A
full copy of this policy can be made available to anyone else who requests it.
A
summary of this policy will be made available to young people and their parents, when they become 'looked
after'. This will contain information on how to access a full copy of the policy.
15. Monitoring
It is proposed to
monitor the effectiveness of the policy on an annual basis. This process will include gaining
the views of carers and young people and incorporate any changes arising from legislation and good practice.
16. References
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Get
in touch with our Contact Centre:
Call:
0845 607 2000 or Email: socialcare@worcestershire.gov.uk
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------